• On GameSpot: Wii Fit tells 10-year-old she's fat

Game-changing smartphones

Bonnie Cha Bonnie Cha, Senior Associate Editor October 23, 2008

I've been covering smartphones for several years now, and I'm not going to lie ... I'm one lucky gal. I get the inside track on upcoming models and of course, I get to play with some of the hottest gadgets in the tech world. However, it's been just as interesting to watch the space change. Over the years, I've seen a quite few standouts that have influenced the smartphone market, whether it be for their design, feature set or technology, and wanted to call them out. I realize everyone might not agree with me, but these are my picks and the reasons why.

I wasn't even at CNET when the Kyocera 7135 came out, but I covered it at my previous job and remember thinking, "What is this? A cell phone and PDA? Cool!" I know the Handspring Treo models came out before it, but it was the first smartphone I had seen and really stuck out in mind. To me, the 7135 is the smartphone equivalent to the Motorola StarTAC. Speaking of Treos, the Palm Treo 650 really seemed to get the formula right in terms of form factor and functionality. The combination of the touch screen, full QWERTY keyboard, and Palm OS really made it the ultimate all-in-one device for business users.

Next, there's the original Motorola Q. The Q was more about the design than anything else. At the time, it was the "thinnest QWERTY device in the world" and the form factor attracted a lot of users and spawned a whole new category of smartphone design. Again, I realize the RIM BlackBerry Pearl wasn't the first model from Research in Motion--hardly. BlackBerrys had long-earned a reputation for being corporate friendly with its strong e-mail capabilities, but the Pearl was the first model to break out that business mode with its slim, cell-phone-like design and multimedia features and bring it to the hands of general consumers.

Last but not least, the Apple iPhone and T-Mobile G1. Whether you love or hate Apple, the company set a new standard with the iPhone. From its multitouch screen to the integrated multimedia features to the ease of use, the iPhone acts as a benchmark for all other touch-screen smartphones. Included in that group is the T-Mobile G1, and while it didn't quite stack up to the iPhone in terms of design and intuitiveness, the G1 did impress with the Google Android operating system. There's huge potential for the G1 (and any Android devices after it) to become powerful minicomputers as developers create more applications for the open platform.

More Resources
Editors' top smartphones,
See all the latest smartphone reviews,
Cell phone buying guide,
Dialed In podcast
Product name
Palm Treo 650 (AT&T)
Play CNET Video
Close

Palm Treo 650 (AT&T)

Motorola Q (Verizon Wireless)
Play CNET Video
Close

Motorola Q (Verizon Wireless)

RIM BlackBerry Pearl - black (T-Mobile)
Play CNET Video
Close

RIM BlackBerry Pearl - black (T-Mobile)

Apple iPhone 3G (16GB, black)
Play CNET Video
Close

Apple iPhone 3G (16GB, black)

T-Mobile G1 (black)
Play CNET Video
Close

T-Mobile G1 (black)

PriceCheck PricesCheck PricesCheck Prices$0.01 to $349.99Check PricesCheck Prices
CNET editors' rating
Average user rating
Review date January 08, 2003 February 01, 2005 May 24, 2006 September 06, 2006 July 11, 2008 October 15, 2008
The Bottom Line The 7135 is a complete, feature-rich phone/PDA hybrid that would've been even more attractive had it come out sooner. Though it has its shortcomings, the Palm Treo 650 offers solid performance and adds some key features to maintain its reign as smart-phone leader. The Motorola Q lives up to much of the hype by offering good call quality, an excellent multimedia experience, and the essential productivity tools, all wrapped up in a sexy little package. Though nothing revolutionary, the addition of multimedia features and the already solid e-mail capabilities make the RIM BlackBerry Pearl an attractive device for business users and consumers alike. The iPhone 3G delivers on its promises by adding critical features and sharper call quality. The iTunes App Store is pretty amazing, and the 3G support is more than welcome. Critical features still are missing, and the battery depletes quickly under heavy use, but the iPhone 3G is a big improvement over the original model. While we're not in love with the design and would have liked some additional features, the real beauty of the T-Mobile G1 is the Google Android platform, as it has the potential to make smartphones more personal and powerful. That said, it's not quite there yet, so for now, the G1 is best suited for early adopters and gadget hounds, rather than consumers and business users.
Similar ProductsCompare more productsCompare more productsCompare more productsCompare more productsCompare more productsCompare more products
Features
Carrier Verizon Wireless
Cingular Wireless
Info unavailableInfo unavailableInfo unavailableInfo unavailable
RAM installed size 16 MB
Info unavailable 64 MB
64 MB
Info unavailable 192 MB
Color support 16-bit (64K colors)
16-bit (64K colors)
16-bit (64K colors)
16-bit (64K colors)
32-bit (128K colors)
65K colors
Talk time Up to 150 min
Up to 360 min
Up to 240 min
210 min
Up to 600 min
Up to 406 min
Built-in devices Touch screen
Speaker
Keypad
Display
Antenna
Microphone
Display
Antenna
Camera
Stereo speakers
Antenna
Camera
Keyboard
Display
Antenna
Camera
Camera
Digital player
Camera
Flash memory form factorInfo unavailableInfo unavailable MiniSD
microSD / TransFlash
Info unavailableInfo unavailable
Packaged contentsInfo unavailable Hands-free headset
Info unavailableInfo unavailableInfo unavailableInfo unavailable
Service Provider Verizon Wireless
AT&T (formerly Cingular)
Info unavailable T-Mobile
ATT
T-Mobile
Band / modeInfo unavailable 1800
190
850
900
Info unavailable GSM 850/900/1800/1900 (Quadband)
WCDMA (UMTS) / GSM 850/900/1800/1900
GSM 850/900/1800/1900 (Quadband) / UMTS 1700/2100 (Dual Band)
Cellular technology 1xRRT
CDMA 800/1900 and Analog 800
Info unavailable GSM
GSM
WCDMA (UMTS) / GSM
Info unavailable
Weight 6.6 oz
6.3 oz
4.1 oz
3.2 oz
4.7 oz
5.6 oz
OS provided Palm OS 4.1
Palm OS 5.4
Microsoft Windows Mobile 5.0 Smartphone Edition
BlackBerry Handheld Software
Apple MacOS X
Android
Height 4 in
4.4 in
4.6 in
4.2 in
4.6 in
4.6 in
Input device type Keypad
Stylus
Touch-screen
Stylus
Keyboard
5-way navigation button
Touch-screen
Wheel
Keyboard
5-way navigation button
Trackball
Keyboard
Touch-screen
Trackball
Keyboard
Touch-screen
Wireless InterfaceInfo unavailableInfo unavailableInfo unavailable Bluetooth
IEEE 802.11b
IEEE 802.11g
Bluetooth 2.0 EDR
Info unavailable
Service & support details type 1 year warranty
Info unavailableInfo unavailable Limited warranty
1-year warranty
Info unavailable
Clock speed 33 MHz
312 MHz
Info unavailableInfo unavailableInfo unavailable 528 MHz
Wireless connectivity IrDA
IrDA
Bluetooth
IrDA
Bluetooth
Bluetooth 2.0
Bluetooth 2.0
IEEE 802.11b
IEEE 802.11g
Bluetooth 2.0 EDR
Full specificationsFull specificationsFull specificationsFull specificationsFull specificationsFull specificationsFull specifications
Buying choices